Netflix's The Witcher has accumulated a fair amount of criticism over the three seasons, though it continues to fall into Netflix's top TV shows list. The third season of the fantasy series has garnered moderately positive reviews, with many fans giving an emotional farewell to Henry Cavill as Geralt of Rivia.
The showrunners have promised an exciting continuation of The Witcher following Cavill's exit and Liam Hemsworth's introduction as the titular character. However, this has not squelched the skepticism of dedicated fans. With the series' popularity waning since the successful first season, this recast could likely be the final nail in the hit show's coffin.
Yennefer and Geralt Are a Main Plot Point
One way Cavill's Geralt has captured the attention and hearts of fans is the romance with Anya Chalotra's Yennefer of Vengerberg. Within the various subplots in the series, the complicated dynamic between Yennefer and Geralt has been a fan favorite. The relationship first sparked in Season 1, Episode 5, "Bottled Appetites," and has been a focal point throughout the three seasons.
Season 3 began in an uncertain time for Yennefer and Geralt's relationship. Though the pair clearly still had affection for one another, Geralt had yet to forgive her for putting Ciri in danger. However, by Season 3, Episode 5, "The Art of Illusion," the couple had officially rekindled their romance. This was a high point in the latest season, exciting viewers with the prospect of seeing Yennefer and Geralt finally as a seemingly unified, inseparable couple. Unfortunately, the chemistry between the two characters is jeopardized by the recast.
Viewers can expect the writers to continue telling a heartwarming, fiery romance in Season 4 of The Witcher. However, there's no denying that Chalotra and Cavill's chemistry on-screen convinced the audience of this genuine love between Geralt and Yennefer. Portraying this love story of Yen and the "same" Geralt will be a challenge for Hemsworth to pull off, considering the audience's attachment to the original Geralt actor. If he fails to depict the Witcher viewers know and love, this will also shatter the believability of the beloved romance.
The Chemistry in The Witcher Won't Be The Same
If Hemsworth is unable to live up to the legacy Cavill has left in his wake, this will alter not just the romance subplot but the dynamic of the whole Witcher family. The wholesome relationship between Yennefer, Geralt, and Ciri was a refreshing aspect of Season 3. Compared to his loner lifestyle in Season 1, the family Geralt created is highlighted at critical moments, such as in the Battle of Aretuza in Season 3, Episode 6, "Everyone Has a Plan 'Till They Get Punched."
The family dynamic of this trio was a key aspect in the romantic evolution of Geralt and Yen's relationship. While they were constantly torn apart by opposing viewpoints, betrayal, and magical intervention, their past was put aside for Ciri. Therefore, focusing on this endearing family story in Season 3 didn't just reunite the two lovers romantically. Putting aside their past differences seemed relatively easy for the Witcher and sorceress now that they have a healthy relationship built on mutual understanding, a common goal, and a child they love like she's their own.
Despite some viewers believing The Witcher has been in a downward spiral since Season 1, this unique family gave the latest season a delightfully wholesome tone. Geralt and Yennefer were the loving yet stern parents to the stubborn and bold Ciri. While this dynamic added to the charm of their romance, this is another layer of their relationship that could be tarnished by the recast. Hemsworth has a lot to live up to when it comes to portraying the love between Yen and Geralt, and the inseparable bond of this found family.
Romance may not be the focal point of Netflix's The Witcher, but it is one of the subplots in the show that has kept fans coming back for each season. Geralt and Yennefer are compelling, enticing characters with the added layer of romance and sexual tension. As parents working together to protect and raise their child, the couple has evolved into a representation of an endearing family dynamic. If Liam Hemsworth is to capture this same wholesomeness in future seasons, he will have to portray Geralt with the same credibility as Henry Cavill.
While fans can rely on the excellent performance of Freya Allan's Ciri to carry the next plot, which is likely to be more Ciri-centric than ever, the series' reputation remains unknown following the recast of the titular character. If Hemsworth does not live up to expectations, The Witcher risks falling into the category of Netflix shows that started off strong before enduring a startling downfall.